StayCurrentMD · Neuroblastoma: Update Course 2016
Follow
Video25 min·Published Jul 2017Older

Neuroblastoma: Update Course 2016

With Dr. CCHMC Pediatric Surgery · StayCurrentMD
Try
Intelligent Search· scoped to neuroblastoma · not medical adviceSearch the whole library →

More about neuroblastoma

same diagnosisDive deeper → Neuroblastoma (26 items)

More from Dr. Surgery

same expert · first-hand onlyDive deeper → Dr. CCHMC Pediatric Surgery

More from StayCurrentMD

same institutionDive deeper → StayCurrentMD
What the experts said31 expert statements · 1 host summary
High-risk neuroblastoma patients continue to have survival rates in the 38-40% range despite aggressive therapy
EpidemiologicalDan
Surgeons overestimated their degree of resection compared to postoperative imaging in 2/3 of cases (66% concordance rate) in the tandem transplant pilot study
ClinicalDan
In a repeat study with COG high-risk patients, surgeons underestimated resection extent while radiologists overcalled it, again showing only 66% concordance, suggesting no correlation between surgeon assessment and imaging
ClinicalDan
The biggest volume response of neuroblastoma tumor occurs with the first two cycles of chemotherapy, with very little response after that (Memorial Sloan Kettering data)
ClinicalDan
More chemotherapy or other treatments like MIBG make the tumor more fibrotic and make subadventitial dissection more difficult
OpinionDan
There is good evidence that aggressive resection improves survival in stage 3 neuroblastoma patients, supported by pre-COG merger studies
Clinical
Surgical complication rate for aggressive neuroblastoma resection is approximately 30% morbidity with mortality less than 1%
EpidemiologicalDan
The Riley study showed the only survivors with stage 4 neuroblastoma were those who had primary tumor resection
Clinical
The Sloan Kettering study suggests stage 4 patients do better with primary tumor resection
Clinical
Kiely's study showed no difference in survival based on extent of resection
Clinical
European studies show no difference in survival based on extent of resection in stage 4 disease
Clinical
High-risk neuroblastoma patients receive 9 different drugs, bone marrow transplantation, and some receive total body radiation, with outrageous morbidity from medical treatment
Clinical
High-risk neuroblastoma treatment includes tandem peripheral blood stem cell transplants (two sequential transplants), followed by immunotherapy and Retin-A
ClinicalDan
High-risk neuroblastoma survival improved from 10% to 30-40% with treatment intensification
Epidemiological
The Georgia study showed 46% survival with transplantation plus immunotherapy plus differentiating agents, but many deaths were due to intensified treatment rather than cancer
Epidemiological
German study of 278 stage 4 high-risk neuroblastoma patients achieved complete resection in almost half and >90% resection in another quarter (75% total achieving >90% resection)
EpidemiologicalDan
German study outcomes: overall survival 45%, event-free survival 33%, local progression-free survival 58%
EpidemiologicalDan
German study showed no difference in overall survival, event-free survival, or local progression-free survival based on completeness of resection
ClinicalDan
European SIOPEN study included 1,324 high-risk neuroblastoma patients (stages 3 and 4) and achieved >95% resection in 76% of patients
EpidemiologicalDan
SIOPEN study surgical mortality was 0.5% with 10% morbidity (30% if including lesser complications)
EpidemiologicalDan
SIOPEN study showed significant improvement in event-free survival and overall survival with >95% resection - the first study to show overall survival benefit
ClinicalDan
SIOPEN study concluded >95% resection results in improvement in event-free survival in high-risk neuroblastoma
ClinicalDan
COG 3973 study (230 patients) showed statistically significant improvement in local relapse-free survival and event-free survival with aggressive resection
ClinicalDan
COG 3973 study was not able to demonstrate improvement in overall survival, possibly due to type 2 error from smaller sample size (230 vs 1,300 in European study)
ClinicalDan
Aggressive neuroblastoma resections using the Kiely subadventitial approach should not be performed by occasional pediatric oncological surgeons doing one case per year or every other year
Opinion
European neuroblastoma procedures are performed in more than 200 hospitals, yet still demonstrated survival improvements despite this distribution
EpidemiologicalDan
Older data shows that if the kidney is removed during neuroblastoma resection, survival is worse; renal preservation leads to better outcomes
ClinicalDan
Renal preservation is important because patients with only one kidney cannot receive as much chemotherapy, which impacts overall survival
ClinicalDan
Aggressive surgical approach to local neuroblastoma recurrence is justified as long as it is not progressive metastatic disease, though prognosis is worse
OpinionDan
New therapies like targeted MIBG therapy may justify surgical removal of bulk disease in recurrent neuroblastoma
OpinionDan
Immunotherapy is effective in the setting of minimal residual disease, so achieving 95% resection may improve the impact of medical therapy on metastatic disease
OpinionDan
German study concluded aggressive surgery is not justified in stage 4 disease, limited operations decrease complications, and there is limited impact on patient outcome
Host summaryDan · not cited in answers